Best Luxury Hotels In The Florida Keys

800 ‘keys’ make up this geographical region, spread across 180 miles and all connected by a web of 42 bridges. It has the most sea turtle nests in the US (plus a world-leading sea turtle hospital) and a coastline proliferated by artificial reefs, many of which were created by sunken ships. Of the islands in the archipelago, Key West is the most famous and lauded for its nightlife. While Key Largo (the second best-known), features in the lyrics of the Beach Boys song ‘Kokomo’, as a quintessential tropical paradise. These are our favourite resorts on the glitzy Florida Keys. 



Key West, Florida

The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

Hotel
(4 stars)

Facing out onto the Atlantic, The Reach has Key West’s only natural sand private beach – and the ocean is right beside the hotel’s poolside, which features a floating gazebo. Seafood, steaks and chops are specialities at the restaurant, Four Marlins, however, guests also have access to the dining options at its sister property, Casa Marina. Sunday brunch at The Reach is famous, taken indoors or on the patio (both have incredible sweeping views). 150 modern bedrooms feature shell headboards, bathrooms with abstract art, and private balconies. This resort is a short walk to the heart of the action, yet far enough away to feel peaceful.

BOOK YOUR STAY
The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

Key Largo, Florida

Baker’s Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection by Hilton

Hotel
(4 stars)

A coastal theme blends with a Tiki style and contemporary island living at this resort on the edge of the Everglades. The family-friendly poolside has its own waterfall and a mobile food truck serving ‘snacks and sips’, or there’s an adult-only swimming area and guests can make use of the private white sandy beach with a host of watersports. Fishing excursions are popular – take part in the hook-and-cook programme to bring your catch back to the kitchen, where the chefs will prepare it for you. Pets are especially welcome too, the hotel even has its own Director of Pet Relations!

BOOK YOUR STAY
Baker’s Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection by Hilton

Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

Hotel
(5 stars)

Situated within the glorious Florida Keys, Playa Largo is the perfect place for guests wishing to bask in the area’s natural beauty, including the nearby John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, known for its underwater marine life and coral reefs. The resort features 177 rooms, including a selection of private bungalows and the luxurious Beach House, a 3-bedroom suite with direct beach access, ideal for those seeking extra privacy and space. Each room at Playa Largo is thoughtfully designed with the ocean and natural surroundings in mind, this maritime theme combined with the room’s emphasis on natural light makes them exceptionally inviting. The rooms are all equipped with flat-screen TVs, minibars, comfy beds, and private balconies or terraces which offer views of either the ocean or picturesque resort gardens. Playa Largo’s expansive grounds are dotted with palm trees and native plants turning the resort into a garden of Eden. 

The Playa Largo has its own large beachfront pool with sweeping views of the bay, an exquisite spa which offers a range of treatments inspired by the Florida Keys, and a well-equipped fitness centre. The Playa Largo is home to many restaurants, including the Sol by the Sea, which serves fresh seafood with a Caribbean flair and the La Marea which serves Mediterranean-inspired cuisine. 

The Playa Largo also has its own private marina where guests can embark on snorkelling, diving, and boating adventures. Additionally, the resort offers a variety of water sports, including paddleboarding and kayaking, as well as eco-tours that highlight the natural beauty of the Keys. The resort is also located near the Florida Keys Wild Bird Rehabilitation Centre and the Dagny Johnson Key Largo Hammock Botanical State Park. The Playa Largo is therefore the perfect choice for guests wishing to enjoy Florida’s beauty and unique wildlife.

BOOK YOUR STAY
Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

Hotel
(5 stars)

Casa Marina is an iconic beachfront resort located on the southern edge of Key West, Florida. Occupying its own private stretch of shoreline, the resort offers direct access to the largest private beach on the island, making it the ideal place for travellers wishing to both relax and explore. The Casa Marina is also only a short distance from popular attractions like Duval Street and the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum. Constructed in 1920 the Casa Marina has hosted many famous guests and notable events throughout its history. Its recent renovations pay homage to this heritage whilst providing guests with the best modern amenities.

Casa Marina’s 311 rooms and suites include several oceanfront suites which boast private balconies that command sweeping views of the Atlantic. The rooms have a tropical feel and boast large windows that allow natural light to flood the space. The rooms all have flat-screen TVs, Wi-Fi, minibars, and luxury bedding. The lobby Casa Marina’s lobby and public spaces feature a tasteful mix of vintage and modern furnishings which combined with natural lighting, help make the resort feel exceptionally welcoming.

The Casa Marina is home to two oceanfront pools which are enveloped by tropical gardens and palm trees. The resort also has a renowned spa as well as a well-equipped fitness centre.

The Casa Marina has many dining options including Sun Sun, a beachfront restaurant which serves fresh seafood and locally inspired dishes, and the Flagler’s Ballroom, which gives guests a taste of the resort’s historic grandeur. Guests can also enjoy drinks at the outdoor RUMba bar, known for its extensive selection of Caribbean rums and divine cocktails.

The Casa Marina also provides guests with the opportunity to go jet skiing, paddleboarding, and snorkelling. The resort’s location also makes it an ideal base for which to explore Key West’s vibrant cultural scene, with attractions like the Southernmost Point and the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory just a short walk or bike ride away.

BOOK YOUR STAY
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

* All the properties and products we feature are independently selected by our editors and contributors. If you buy something we may earn a commission.

Sign up for our newsletter for inspiration, exclusive previews & luxury tips